For years I have been going to concerts and for years I have been frustrated by lead singers who insist on stepping away from the microphone and letting the crowd’s yelling resonate throughout the venue. “I came to hear your voice, not the annoying 16 year old female fanatic next to me” I would think in my head.
I remember when Dashboard Confessional released their live CD/DVD back in 2002, I was so eager to hear the live version of “Hands Down” and Chris Carrabba’s famed intro to the song “This is a song about the best day I can ever remember” only to be disappointed when the whole rest of the song was littered with adolescent girls screaming the lyrics while he steps away from the microphone and smiles. I never understood why artists assumed that fans would rather hear their peers singing along (poorly) than hearing the original author of the song singing a live rendition in person.
It’s something I have complained about for a long time, and thought about for even longer. I always assumed that maybe the singer needed a break in between long notes and that was a good way to catch their breath, or that it simply must be a very gratifying feeling to have thousands of people that you don’t know singing the lyrics to a song your wrote years ago in your bedroom while dreaming of getting a record deal and making it big. But then I also wondered if they ever felt like the crowd was butchering their masterpiece, removing the harmonic and artistic value of the song and replacing it with out-of-tune yelling.
A few years ago The Starting Line released a song called “Given the Chance” where lead singer Kenny Vasoli describes the feeling he gets when he is on tour, in a new town and finally gets to step on stage and hear his fans sing every word of what has been so important to him and the proof that he has arrived as an artist.
“the feeling is screaming out
the words of the things i think about
hearing them coming back
from the crowds mouth is perfect
and when the curtains close
i’ll realize how fast time could go
thanks for everything
you know how much this means
what can i say
that can explain
all this time
i’m loving life
theres not a day
that i can’t say
all this time
i’m living out my dream
what this is to me
is more than words could mean
i guess dreams do come true
this song itself is living proof”
Then today I came across a quote from the lead singer of The Damnwells, Alex Dezen, who might have summed up the emotions of being on stage, hearing the crowd singing back to you the best.
“Back to the Double Door show in Chicago. Does anyone have any footage / pictures from that show they can pass around? I would love to see what went on that night. What a f****** affirmation that was. When we were on tour with the Fray, I used to listen to the crowd sing along with them every night. Three-thousand people singing at the top of their lungs with glorious abandonment—just amazing. So I’m singing the breakdown section of “Kung Fu Grip Kiss” on stage at the Double Door—the part where I accompany myself without the band for a few measures—and I can hear these voices rising up to meet me, hundreds of them. When I stepped away from the microphone, they sang without me. They carried the song back to me and I heard it for the first time, heard it as something living. Thank you.”
Affirmation. Something living. I guess it makes a little more sense to me now, I just wish they would realize that we have just as much fun singing along whether the speakers drown us out or not. I’d rather hear their voice than mine and thousands of other people who aren’t paid to sing for a living.